| Early Draw | 6:45 p.m. | Late Draw | 8:45 p.m. | ||||
| Date | Ice 1 | Ice 2 | Ice 3 | Ice 4 | Ice 2 | Ice 3 | Ice 4 |
| 2/4/2009 | Haslam vs. Lasich | Gaumer vs. Burdett | Zimmerman vs. Cool | McGrath vs. Roper | Lafore vs. Schriks | Graves vs. Gatzke | Richards vs. Wilson |
| 2/11/2009 | McGrath vs. Schriks | Richards vs. Burdett | Graves vs. Lasich | Wilson vs. Roper | Haslam vs. Zimmerman | Gaumer vs. Gatzke | Lafore vs. Cool |
| 2/18/2009 | Gaumer vs. Zimmerman | Haslam vs. McGrath | Burdett vs. Lasich | Richards vs. Lafore | Gatzke vs. Cool | Roper vs.Schriks | Graves vs. Wilson |
| 2/25/2009 | Gatzke vs. Roper | Zimmerman vs. Schriks | Wilson vs. Cool | Graves vs. Lafore | Gaumer vs. McGrath | Haslam vs. Burdett | Richards vs. Lasich |
| 3/4/2009 | McGrath vs. Cool | Burdett vs. Wilson | Haslam vs. Roper | Gaumer vs. Lafore | Graves vs. Zimmerman | Lasich vs. Schriks | Richards vs. Gatzke |
| 3/11/2009 | Graves vs. Burdett | McGrath vs. Gatzke | Cool vs. Schriks | Haslem vs. Richards | Lafore vs. Roper | Lasich vs.Zimmerman | Gaumer vs. Wilson |
| 3/18/2009 | Haslem vs. Gaumer | Richards vs.Cool | Gatzke vs. Zimmerman | Lasich vs. Lafore | McGrath vs. Wilson | Burdett vs. Schriks | Graves vs. Roper |